Since the news broke that Greta Gerwig is developing aChronicles of Narniaremake, many have been wondering who will take onthe iconic roles of the Pevensie siblings, but unfortunately, the perfect choice has already aged out of her role.The Chronicles of Narniafirst originated as fantasy novels by C.S. Lewis, then became even bigger cultural cornerstones when they were adapted to film in the 2000s. Although only three of Lewis’s sevenNarniabooks were brought to life,the movies were still incredibly impactful for generations of audiences, and their remakes are sure to have the same effect.
The problem of casting the Pevensies is both exciting and risky. IfThe Chronicles of Narniaremakeis going to last for seven whole movies, these actors need to be fully dedicated to the franchise and must embody these beloved characters. On top of that, details are important.The Chronicles of Narnia’scast members will have to be the right ages, and arguably, should have some sort of family resemblance. While there is endless young talent in Hollywood these days, there is one actress that comes to mind who is, unfortunately, too old for her ideal role.
Saoirse Ronan Would’ve Been The Perfect Susan Pevensie If Netflix’s Narnia Movie Happened Earlier
Why Ronan Cannot Play Susan
The ideal actor to appear in Greta Gerwig’sChronicles of Narniais Saoirse Ronan as Susan Pevensie. Ronan is a long-time collaborator of Gerwig’s, having appeared in her moviesLady BirdandLittle Women.In fact, these roles have proven that she would make the perfect Susan.As Jo inLittle Women,Ronan embodied the intelligent and kind older sisterwho is completely loyal to her family, regardless of their disagreements. Additionally, Ronan’s portrayal as Lady Bird showcased her ability to act as a young and naive character. Unfortunately though, Ronan will likely not be cast as Susan.
Some could argue that Ronan portrayed a teenage Jo inLittle Women,yet this type of age difference probably would only hurt the newChronicles of Narnia.
At this point, Ronan is much too old to portray Susan inThe Chronicles of Narniaremake. Ronan is 30-years-old at this point, and intheNarnianovels, Susan is 12. Even when she appears as an adult later in the series, Susan is only 21-years-old, which is a nearly decade-long difference in age. In this way,Ronan has aged out of this role.Some could argue that Ronan portrayed a teenage Jo inLittle Women,yet this type of age difference probably would only hurt the newChronicles of Narnia.
Saoirse Ronan Can Still Appear In Greta Gerwig’s Narnia In Another Role
Why Ronan Should Appear In Narnia
Luckily,Susan is far from the only character Ronan could play in Gerwig’sChronicles of Narnia.There are a number of roles within the franchise that are played by adults, and thus, could be given to Ronan. One of the most memorablecharacters is Jadis the White WitchfromThe Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe.Ronan is not only the right age for this role, but it would also be interesting to see her play a villain. There is also the Green Witch, who comes later in the series, but could definitely be a great role for Ronan.
Every Saoirse Ronan Movie Ranked From Worst To Best
Saoirse Ronan has been nominated for several Oscars thanks to her stellar performances, evidenced by this ranking of all of her films.
At this point, Ronan is not officially a part ofNarnia’scast, although there are countless rumors that Gerwig has already hired her. Ronan has firmly denied this. Regardless, Ronanshouldappear inThe Chronicles of Narnia.The actress has already shown that her and Gerwig work well together, and Ronan herself would be a good fit for the franchise. Based on her previous roles,Ronan has shown her dramatic acting chops, especially for big IPs, and it would be particularly exciting to see her in a more magical, fantasy project.
Greta Gerwig’s Remake Could Benefit From Casting Unknowns As The Pevensies
What We Know About Narnia’s Cast Right Now
In some ways, it is probably a good thing that Ronan would appear in the adultNarniacast rather than as a Pevensie. In many ways,Narniacould benefit from casting unknowns as the main characters. While big stars have already proven their talent, they may not be able to commit to a multi-movie franchise. More than that, giving small-time actors a chance to appear in a major film series could be life-changing. Plus, new faces would allow audiences to go into the movie without any bias. The actors would then mesh fully with their characters.
Lucy Pevensie
Georgie Henley
At this point, viewers can only speculate aboutThe Chronicles of Narnia’scast.Only one actor has been officially hired so far, and that is Louis Partridge, who previously appeared in theEnola Holmesfranchise. Although it has not been revealed who Partridge will play, many are assuming he will take on the role of Peter Pevensie. Considering that Partridge is a rising star, it seems likely that the other Pevensies will have a similar level of fame, but currently, there is no telling where exactlyThe Chronicles of Narniawill go.
The Chronicles of Narnia
The Chronicles of Narniais a fantasy franchise based on the seven-book series written by C.S. Lewis between 1950 and 1956. The series is set in the magical world of Narnia, where children from our world are transported to fulfill prophecies, battle evil forces, and restore peace under the guidance of Aslan, a mystical lion. The franchise has seen multiple adaptations, including a BBC television series in the late 1980s, three major Hollywood films between 2005 and 2010, and an upcoming reboot by Netflix, which has generated significant anticipation. The franchise is beloved for its rich allegorical storytelling, blending Christian themes with epic fantasy elements.
