Ryan Murphy’s new horror series,Grotesquerie, becomes a streaming success after four episodes. Co-created by Murphy, Jon Robin Baitz, and Joe Baken, their new FX series follows a female detective who teams up with a local nun to uncover the origin of a series of heinous crimes that are impacting not only their community, but also their own personal lives. Emmy winner Niecy Nash-Betts (Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story) leadsGrotesquerie’s castalongside Courtney B. Vance, Nicholas Alexander Chavez, Micaela Diamond, Raven Goodwin, Lesley Manville, and Travis Kelce.

Now, after airing only four episodes on FX, Ryan Murphy’s new horror series has become a streaming success on Hulu.Grotesquerieranks eighth onReelgood’s Top 10 TV shows chartfor the week of September 26 to October 2. It ranked just below fellow FX/Hulu showsOnly Murders in the BuildingandThe Old Manin the sixth and seventh place spots. Check out the full list below:

Reelgood Top 10 Shows Right Now Week of September 26 — 2, 2024

Why You Should Watch Grotesquerie

Ryan Murphy Delivers Yet Again

Grotesquerieavoids the campiness often associated with Ryan Murphy, offering something more serious and introspective.

Grotesquerieis from the mind of Ryan Murphy, the creator ofAmerican Horror Story, making his new series a must-watch for fans of his horror anthology, especially as the wait forAmerican Horror Storyseason 13continues. Like his previous show,Grotesqueriehas garnered positive reactionsfrom critics and audiences for its boldly shocking content, including unforgettable images that linger long after viewing. Critics emphasize the show’s deep reflections on morality, noting its dark and gothic tone similar toSevenorTrue Detective. In turn,Grotesquerieavoids the campiness often associated with Ryan Murphy, offering something more serious and introspective.

A nun in Grotesquerie with the Hulu interface in the background

What Time New Episodes Of Grotesquerie Release On FX & Hulu

The Travis Kelce-starring horror TV show Grotesquerie kicks off on September 25, with new episodes following each Wednesday on FX & Thursday on Hulu.

Many critics agree thatGrotesqueriesucceeds because of its strong cast, including a charismaticperformance by Niecy Nash-Betts, whose presence alone is reason enough to tune in, regardless of any narrative shortcomings there may be. There is also much praise for Lesley Manville, who received an Oscar nomination for her performance in Paul Thomas Anderson’sPhantom Thread, who turns in another standout performance, this time delivering some truly absurd lines. Overall, critics considerGrotesqueriea smart procedural grounded by a strong cast, making it a must-watch for fans of dark, character-driven horror.

Niecy Nash-Betts in Grotesquerie

Grotesqueriefeatures Travis Kelcein his first major acting role.

Audience reactions toGrotesqueriehave been more mixed, but still mostly positive, indicated by its 70% score on Rotten Tomatoes' Popcornmeter with 100+ ratings.Viewers are enjoying everything from its intriguing dark tone, high production value, and stellar acting – particularly from Niecy Nash-Betts. For others, the show’s grotesque imagery and twisted narrative have kept them hooked and coming back for more. If you enjoy unsettling horror with psychological depth and don’t mind a slow burn,Grotesquerieis for you. However, it might not be for everyone.

What Grotesquerie’s Streaming Success Means For Ryan Murphy

His Recent Hot Streak Continues

Ryan Murphy is already a major television mogul thanks to shows likeGleeandAmerican Horror Story, thoughhis recent output has been especially impressivewithAmerican Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez,Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story, and now,Grotesquerie. The first season ofAmerican Sports Story, focusing on the rise and fall of the former NFL player, premiered on September 17 to generally favorable reviews, but still has four more episodes to go. The second season ofMonsterwas released on September 19 on Netflix and was another number-one global hit for the streamer.

80%

Grotesquerie

Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score

70%

Premiered September 25 on FX,Grotesquerieis Ryan Murphy’s third new series to see success in such a short amount of time. With an 80% score on Rotten Tomatoes, reviews have been mostly positive, praising its bold and unsettling approach that blends gothic and noir elements with strong performances, especially from Niecy Nash-Betts. While viewership on FX has been somewhat weak, averaging only about 273,000 viewers per episode,Grotesquerie’s streaming success suggests that many more viewers are watching the show on Hulu.

Our Take On Grotesquerie’s Streaming Success

Will It Continue?

Grotesquerie, with its intriguing setup across its first four episodes, has captivated critics and audiences alike. At the time of writing, the show has only aired four episodes, with the next two premiering on October 9. With six more total episodes to go, it remains to be seen if Ryan Murphy’s new horror series can maintain this high degree of quality throughout its first season. Given the creator’s track record, it likely should, andGrotesqueriecould be entered into the pantheon of successfulRyan Murphy shows, perhaps on the same level asAmerican Horror Story.

Grotesquerie

Cast

Grotesquerie: In this crime drama, a detective and a nun delve into a series of heinous crimes with personal ties, confronting their own struggles while unraveling a sinister web. Their investigation raises profound questions, revealing unsettling truths that challenge their perceptions and deepen the mystery.