One of the most pivotal events ofStar Trek’s 21st century happens right now.Star Trek: Deep Space Nineseason 3, episodes 11 & 12, “Past Tense”, takesCommander Benjamin Sisko(Avery Brooks), Dr. Julian Bashir (Alexander Siddig), and Lieutenant Jadzia Dax (Terry Farrell) back to the first week of September 2024. Dax is helped by billionaire Chris Brynner (Jim Metzler), whereasthe police assume that Sisko and Bashir are part of San Francisco’s unhoused population, and take them to the city’s Sanctuary District, where disenfranchised residents are subject to systemic violence, inequity, and hostility. This tension leads to the historic Bell Riots, and the start of sweeping social changes.
This part of theStar Trektimeline was recently revisited inStar Trek: Picardseason 2, when La Sirena’s crew traveled to Los Angeles in April 2024. As a nod toStar Trek: DS9’s “Past Tense”,signs for Los Angeles' Sanctuary District are visible in the background ofPicard’s sets. Like Sisko and Bashir, Captain Cristobál Rios (Santiago Cabrera) doesn’t have modern ID, but Rios' Latino heritage puts him at odds with L.A.’s ICE patrols, who mistakenly assume that Rios is an illegal immigrant. Even withStar Trektime traveling closer to the era of production,there’s no ignoring the tensions that will lead toDS9’s Bell Riots.
Picard Just Tied Into DS9’s Bell Riots (But Jean-Luc Won’t Meet Sisko)
Star Trek: Picard’s season 2 time travel sends Jean-Luc’s crew to 2024 Los Angeles. Meanwhile, DS9’s' Sisko is in San Francisco during the Bell Riots.
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine’s Bell Riots Explained
Benjamin Sisko Becomes Gabriel Bell To Create Social Reform
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine’s Bell Riots are a turning point inStar Trek’s historythat starts the kind of social reform that makes a united Earth, and ultimately, the United Federation of Planets, possible. Ostensibly designed to help San Francisco’s homeless population,the Sanctuary Districts fail the people they’re designed to support.Without housing, medicine, or job opportunities that were promised to them, disillusioned residents turn to violence or die waiting for help that never comes. District resident Gabriel Bell (John L. Bennett) is supposed to lead a riot that makes people realize the Sanctuary Districts aren’t working, but when Bell is killed, Sisko takes Bell’s place to ensure history remains on track.
San Francisco’s Sanctuary District residents have nicknames based on their needs:
As Gabriel Bell, Sisko needs to guide history towards the future that births the Federation. When one ghost, Coleridge (Frank Military), decides to take hostages,Sisko determines that an unemployed family man named Michael Webb (Bill Smitrovich) is going to be the face of the Bell Riots, not Coleridge. Once eyes are on the Sanctuary District, the clincher in the Bell Riots is using the internet to share stories like Webb’s, even while the government sends police to the Sanctuary Districts to quell the protesters. The documented violence is proof that rioters have reason to protest, sparking sweeping social reform across the US.
InStar Trek: Prodigy, Vulcan Starfleet Academy cadet Maj’el (Michaela Dietz) cites the Bell Riots as an example of a"causal temporal loop", wherein time travel to a historical event is what causes the event in the first place.
Why Star Trek: DS9’s Bell Riots Matter
30 Years Ago, DS9 Foresaw A Lot Of Modern Social Issues
Looking back from the very week that “Past Tense” takes place,Star Trek: Deep Space Nine’sBell Riots are eerily prescient. There’s an enormous class disparity between the Sanctuary District residents and Dax’s experiences with tech billionaire Chris Brynner. Brynner and his friends are aware but indifferent to the systemic issues that made the Sanctuary Districts a reality. Those with privilege assume that people are trapped in the District by their own fault. Instead,the failure of the Sanctuary District represents larger systemic issues that those in power are unwilling to solve. Civil servants working in the system become apathetic, even when they actually want to help people.
When Bashir asks how people of the 21st century let it get so bad, the answers are right outside our windows.
InStar Trek: Deep Space Nine,the Bell Riots are important enough to spark real change. Stories from relatable people stuck in the system are enough to convince those outside looking in that it’s possible to make a difference by enacting social reform. In reality, however, so many voices raised in protest get lost in a chorus of issues, to be met with indifference as hollow as Brynner’s. When Bashir asks how people of the 21st century let it get so bad, the answers are right outside our windows. We don’t haveStar Trek: Deep Space Nine’s Bell Riots happening right now, but wedohaveStar Trekas a road map to a future that it’s still possible to create.
