Ryan Murphy’s new horror seriesGrotesqueriehas arrived on FX and Hulu, and the show’s Rotten Tomatoes scores reveal how it stacks up againstAmerican Horror Story. First announced in February this year, Murphy co-created the series with Jon Robin Baitz and Joe Baken, after his five-year exclusive development deal with Netflix ended in 2023. Starring Niecy Nash-Betts as a small-town detective who turns to a Catholic nun (Micaela Diamond) to help solve a series of disturbing crimes,Grotesquerierecently debutedits first two episodes on September 25.
With the initial scores forGrotesqueriebeginning to roll in on review aggregator siteRotten Tomatoes, audiences can now see how Murphy’s new horror show compares withAmerican Horror Story. Currentlyboasting a 75% critical score and 79% audience score,Grotesquerieappears to fall just short of some ofAHS’ more acclaimed seasons, suchas 1984andCoven, but is stillon par with the majority of the ratings for Murphy’s long-running anthology show. However, it is important to note that only the first two episodes have been released, and these scores may fluctuate as the season continues. Check out the ratings forGrotesquerieand each season ofAHSbelow:
75%
79%
AHS: 1984(2019)
88%
76%
85%
84%
90%
80%
50%
77%
70%
68%
74%
57%
73%
52%
72%
71%
42%
64%
61%
What Grotesquerie’s Rotten Tomatoes Scores Mean For Ryan Murphy’s New Show
FX May Be Looking To Fill A Gap Left By American Horror Story Ending
As a series producer and creator,Murphy already boasts an impressive collection of showsamong his extensive list of credits. WhileAmerican Horror Storyand hisNetflix true-crime anthologyMonstermay currently be at the forefront of audiences’ minds, he has also been involved in everything from such teen comedies asPopularandGleeto the procedural dramas9-1-1and its Texas-based spinoff9-1-1: Lone Star.
The Best American Horror Story Episode From Each Of The Show’s 12 Seasons
American Horror Story is an addictive horror anthology series, full of intense twists and turns throughout the shows run, with some standout episodes.
However,Grotesquerie’srelatively strong start once again shows that much of his strength continues to lie in the horror and thriller genres. While Murphy’s other Netflix show,The Watcher,fell well short of the interest and audience acclaim generated byMonster’sexplorations of Jeffrey Dahmer and the Menendez brothers,American Horror Story’snotable longevity has resulted in it becoming the benchmarkagainst which many of his other projects are measured.
WithAmerican Horror Storylargely expected to concludewith the as-yet-untitled season 13, FX will likely be looking for a potential replacement. While it is unclear whetherGrotesqueriecould potentially fill that gap remains to be seen, the show’s initial reactions seem promising, and with Murphy no longer being tied down by his first-look deal with Netflix, he could further spread his wings to help build out other projects.
Our Take On Grotesquerie’s Future
The Show Needs To Further Differentiate Itself From American Horror Story
In an entertainment landscape where networks and streamers are increasingly likely to cut a promising series short based on lackluster viewership numbers,Murphy’s new show appears to be off to a strong start. Even if it does not quite match the heights of some ofAmerican Horror Story’smore popular seasons, it is possible the show will continue to drive enough interest to see it continue beyond season 1.
What Time New Episodes Of Grotesquerie Release On FX & Hulu
The Travis Kelce-starring horror TV show Grotesquerie kicks off on September 25, with new episodes following each Wednesday on FX & Thursday on Hulu.
However, in the event FX does decide to look towardGrotesquerieas a serious replacement forAmerican Horror Story, it will be interesting to see whether it adopts the same anthology format. Though the approach has already delivered some of Murphy’s most notable successes, it will be important forGrotesquerieto stand on its own merits and avoid simply becoming anotherAHSknockoff.
Grotesquerie
Cast
Grotesquerie: In this crime drama, a detective and a nun delve into a series of heinous crimes with personal ties, confronting their own struggles while unraveling a sinister web. Their investigation raises profound questions, revealing unsettling truths that challenge their perceptions and deepen the mystery.
