After six years of playingMagic: The Gatheringoff and on, I started playingMagic: The Gathering Online,and you should too.MTGis one of the most dominant trading card games on the market. The franchise continues to pump out quality fun sets from its original ideas, including beloved franchises in crossover sets dubbed Universes Beyond, the next one being withFinal FantasyCommander decks. The most recent set, Aetherdrift, is a high-octane racing theme that has added a new speed to the chaotic tabletop title.
Magic: The Gathering Online, orMTGOfor short, became the first online video game version of the franchisewhen it released in 2002. It has seen a few major upgrades in the two-plus decades it has been out, with the most recent coming in 2014. Despite the recent push towardsMagic: The Gathering Arena,MTGOremains a popular title for experienced fans and new players. The one downside is that it fails to get the proper marketing, so it can be tricky to discover unless directly looking into playingMTGin an online format.
Why I’m Playing Magic: The Gathering Online In 2025
An Old Way To Play Magic
As someone who has been fascinated byMTGfor years but never really had the funds or time to create a real-life deck and go to events, I had a sense of relief upon findingMagic: The Gathering Online.MTGOis a place where anyone can go to play every format of the game, with a plethora of other users always available. It is an incredibly low investment but rewards those who can dedicate their time to it. Much likeArena,it is entirely possible to playMTGOfor free, though a small purchase can help unlock many other goodies.
D&D and Magic: The Gathering Are Teasing Their Next Big Crossover Project
D&D and Magic: The Gathering appear to be crossing over with an unexpected plane as the next focus and a potential new mix of fantasy to explore.
MTGOdoes lack much of the social interaction and feeling of in-person events, but that is largely its only drawback. It can also be its biggest strength. For fans ofMTGwho don’t feel comfortable with in-person events for various reasons or can’t find the time,MTGOoffers a completely safe and virtual experience. Users can play whenever they find the time and comfortably leave if something goes awry.
MTGOdoes offer some social features like opt-in chat and clans, but everything is optional.
Overall,MTGOwas the perfect find for someone like me who wasn’t sure about big deck investments and was lacking the time to go to real events. All the quality-of-life elements and generous features also help avoid much of the feeling of being left behind by stronger cards. In the two-plus weeks I have had the game, I have found myself drawn to the title either to create decks or battle out against tough competition inCommander mode with its new bracket system.
How Magic: The Gathering Online Gameplay Works
A User-Friendly Experience
MTGOis its own entity that must be downloaded from the site and used by its client. On the base level, anyone can make an account for free and have access to a bunch of common and uncommon cards to make decks with. Now, these cards won’t create any incredibly strong decks, but they are perfect for new players or those who just want a little taste ofMTGnow and then.This free account does have some limitations, like not being able to access the Trade function and Leagues, which are tournaments.
Magic: The Gathering’s Aetherdrift Set Is A Mess, & That’s Okay
Magic: The Gathering’s first set of 2025 is all over the place, but Aetherdrift is meant to feature multiple planes and different characters.
However,for a $5 upgrade, players will get access to over 5000 cards and remove all the free account restrictions. Yes, this is not as “free” asArena, which has its own issues, but a $5 purchase to play anything on the game with access to over 5000 cards is a great deal. However, this is not the end of “free” cards.MTGOhas a handful of services that will give free cards or rental decks. This includes bots that will trade free cards, though usually with daily limits, and websites that rent high-tier decks for a monthly subscription cost.
Leagues/Tournaments are whereMTGObecomes an optional investment. These events can reward valuable cards and in-game currencies known as Play-Points, Tickets, and Competitive-Play points. However,these tournaments often need to be entered with the use of Tickets, which can be bought for $1 each. Entering these tournaments and spending the extra money comes down to how much faith a player has to win enough to make their money back and more.
Another bonus ofMTGOis its redemption system. While this has been lessened in recent years,players can collect all the digital cards of new sets and then redeem them for physical copies. This does come with an upfront cost of around $45, but it is a major save compared to trying to buy them physically. This is one feature thatArenaand any other onlineMTGplatforms don’t have and can’t even compete with.
How Does MTG Online Compare To MTG Arena?
Quality Vs. Quantity
Though both games have their pros and cons, the games can largely be summed up in one sentence.MTGOis the iconic fullMTGexperience, whileArenais the more modernized version for new or casual players.Arenais great in that is a free experience for everything, but it can also have some major downsides. Without major grinding, players will have to buy new packs to obtain new cards, and this system has been notorious for being akin to a gacha game.
I’m Worried Gacha Games Like Genshin Impact & Infinity Nikki Are Changing AAA Games Forever
Gacha games have grown immensely in popularity since the rise of Genshin Impact, but its meteoric rise may be doing more harm than good.
Arena’s other two major downsides are that it lacks modes and is subject to the usual live-service game rules.The latter means that digital cards can be buffed/nerfed, so a deck that may be good one week can be nerfed to near unplayability the next. The modes are another issue, asArenagenerally sticks to the core Standard modes, and misses out on the most played format of the franchise, Commander, and all thebest Commander decks.
Why I Recommend You Play Online
A Product Worth Trying
If you want a simple and casualMTGexperience, thenArenais the way to go. However, if you are looking for a realMTGexperience with better competition and more rewards,MTGOis the best choice. It may not be as flashy asArena, but it makes up for this with everything else it offers.To get all this for a base $5 one-time upgrade is huge, and anything else players want to invest in is just a bonus. At worst, you lose $5 and figure out that you enjoy another method, likeArenaor in-person play, more.
MTGOmay be the older product, but as of now, it stands as the superior one in my eyes. It is an extremely friendly, convenient, and even cheaper version of playingMTGwithout having to worry about the drawbacks of the other versions. The investment may seem like a big one at times, but it comes down to what you want from the online experience, as just playing to fill the urge is a small investment. I’m certainly happy that I started playingMagic: The Gathering Online, and I’d gladly recommend that you try it too.
